The Power of the Rough Draft: Why Your "Mess" is Actually Progress
- Chelsea Tornetto
- Jun 8
- 4 min read
After 17 years in the classroom, I’ve seen thousands of first drafts. I’ve seen essays written in sparkly purple gel pen, stories with more cross-outs than actual words, and paragraphs that wandered so far off-topic they ended up in a different zip code.
And you know what? That's totally okay!
Why? Because a messy first draft means a student is thinking. It means they aren't paralyzed by the fear of the red pen. But when we sit down to write our own books as adults, we suddenly forget everything we taught our students. We expect our first draft to look like the best-selling book on the shelf.
If you’re struggling to get started, here is a secret from a teacher-turned-author: You have full permission to be messy.
The "Scholastic" Illusion
When you walk into a bookstore, you’re seeing the result of a dozen rounds of professional editing, proofreading, and polishing, from the biggest publishers in the business. You are seeing the final exam. But as an author, you are currently in the "brainstorming" phase.
Comparing your first draft to a published book is like comparing a 7th-grader’s rough sketch to a Da Vinci. It’s not a fair fight! My first drafts for my five published books? They were disasters! But those "bad" drafts were the essential clay I needed to mold the final story.
Why a "Bad" Rough Draft is a Good Sign
A messy draft is proof of courage. It means you’ve silenced the inner critic that tells you your ideas aren't good enough. In my classroom, I used to tell my students: "I can't grade a blank page."
The same goes for publishing. You can't edit a blank screen. You can't send an "idea" to an agent—you have to send a finished manuscript. Writing a "bad" first draft is the only way to get to the "good" second (or third...or fourth) one.
How to Embrace the Mess
If you’re feeling stuck, it’s usually because your "Editor Brain" has shown up to a meeting that only the "Creator Brain" was invited to. Here are a few teacher-approved strategies to kick the editor out of the room so you can get those words down:
Change the Font to Something "Silly": This sounds ridiculous, but it works! Switch your word processor to Comic Sans or a bubbly handwriting font. It’s psychologically much harder to obsess over "literary greatness" when your words look like a lemonade stand sign or a note passed in class. Save the Times New Roman for the final draft.
The [Bracket] Method: Don't let a missing detail stop your momentum. If you can’t think of the perfect name for a character or a specific historical fact, just put it in brackets and keep going.
Example: "They walked into the [cool-sounding restaurant] and ordered [some kind of fancy pasta]." Your goal is to finish the scene, not the research.
Write the "Bad" Version on Purpose: Sometimes we get stuck trying to find the "perfect" way to say something. Tell yourself, "I am going to write the cheesiest, most cliché version of this conversation possible just to get through it." Often, once the "bad" version is on the page, the "good" version naturally starts to reveal itself.
Try "Zero Drafting": A first draft is for you; a "zero draft" is just for the paper. Tell yourself this version doesn't even count. It’s just you telling yourself the story. It can be bullet points, fragments, or half-sentences. If the story is moving from your brain to the screen or notebook, you’re winning.
The 15-Minute Sprint: Set a timer. Commit to writing for 15 minutes without hitting the backspace key. If you get stuck, write "I don't know what happens next," over and over until the next plot point hits you. The physical act of typing keeps the creative gears turning.
Change Your Scenery: If the blinking cursor on your laptop is intimidating, grab a yellow legal pad and a pen. Go sit on your porch or at a noisy park. Sometimes a change in medium—moving from digital to analog—tricks your brain into lowering its expectations.
Just Do It
Eventually, you will go back and fix the typos. You’ll tighten the plot, find the perfect adjectives, and smooth out those clunky transitions. But you can't polish a diamond that hasn't been mined yet.
For today? Just focus on the "dirt". Celebrate the fact that you are brave enough to be a beginner. Your first draft doesn’t need to be "good." It just needs to be done.
Want to join a community of picture book authors just like you? Check out our Profitable Picture Books Program! It's an affordable monthly membership that comes with a comprehensive online course, private Facebook group, and monthly check-ins with me!
Disclaimer: This blog post may contain affiliate links to products we enjoy using ourselves. Should you choose to use these links, At Home Author may earn affiliate commissions at no additional cost to you.
Comments